Skip links

Episode 9: Tiger and Peacock (with Special Guest Justin Evans)

It’s another round of the fan favorite “THE PRICE IS WHAT?!?!?!” where Chris searches the internet to find some of the strangest things that people have actually purchased. Here are the items but make sure you go listen before you look!!


1. Justin Timberlake’s half-eaten French toast- $1,025

Left behind after an interview with a New York radio station, the old food was sold for $1,025 in 2000. A DJ put the leftover breakfast up for auction, and a 19-year-old superfan placed the winning bid.

2. A suit of armor for a guinea pig- $1,150

guinea pig armorguinea pig knight

The creator promised that the tiny hand-made suit (and matching helmet) would keep a “guinea pig protected and secure in all situations.” He sold it for $1,150 in 2013.

3. Serial Killer’s Fingernails- Roy Noris’ fingernails- $9.99

Serial Killer Roy Norris. “In 1979, Lawrence Bittaker and prison buddy Roy Norris set out on a mission to pick up young girls and brutally rape, torture, and kill them.” The pair claimed 5 victims, but authorities felt the real number was much higher. Three of Roy’s fingernails, affixed with a small piece of tape, to a “recycled” card (the back of a portion of a color Christmas card), approx. 4″x2.5″ in size. He’s penned a long note authenticating the nails, which fills half the card. At bottom right, he’s signed IN FULL over a perfect right thumbprint, in black ink. Absolutely guaranteed authentic for life, or your money back. “

4. A latex Casey Anthony mask- $999,900

casey anthony mask

Originally made for a parody video. It was called “possibly the most frightening mask on the planet.” It finally sold for $999,900 in 2011.


Follow along wherever you listen to podcasts: